The Retreat from Mons By one who shared in it — Background and Themes
Edition facts
The catalog record for The Retreat from Mons By one who shared in it — Background and Themes provides practical reading context through 57,069 words, 4 hr 9 min estimated reading time, and 6 detected text sections.
The text analysis averages about 18.6 words per sentence, while the detected sections provide another way to judge how the source is divided.
Project Gutenberg metadata also associates the work with “World War, 1914-1918 -- Campaigns -- Western Front,” connecting these edition facts with the source record’s subject description.
Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.
How this score is calculated
- Description quality20 pts
- Title & short description10 pts
- Source metadata20 pts
- Text length15 pts
- Chapters / structure15 pts
- EPUB file integrity20 pts
Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.
Read the Text
1. Mobilisation 2. The Sailing of the Force 3. The Landing of the Force 4. Up Country 5. The Marshalling of the Armies 6. Mons 7. Mons (_continued_) 8. The Retreat Begins 9. The Second Day 10. An Interlude 11. Wednesday, the 26th of August 12. Wednesday, the 26th of August (_continued_) 13. The Retreat Continues 14. Past Compiègne 15. The Final Stages
General Sir H. Smith-Dorrien . . . _Frontispiece_
Field-Marshal Viscount French
General Sir Douglas Haig
Map of Country from Mons to Paris
FIRST EXPEDITIONARY FORGE
_General Officer Commanding-in-Chief the British Forces:_ FIELD-MARSHAL SIR J. D. P. FRENCH.
_Chief of the General Staff:_ LIEUTENANT-GENERAL SIR A. J. MURRAY.
_Adjutant-General:_ MAJOR-GENERAL SIR C. F. N. MACREADY.
_Quartermaster-General:_ MAJOR-GENERAL SIR W. R. ROBERTSON.
_General Officer Commanding-in-Chief_-- LIEUTENANT-GENERAL SIR DOUGLAS HAIG.
_General Officer Commanding_--MAJOR-GENERAL S. H. LOMAX.
_Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL F. I. MAXSE. 1st Batt. Coldstream Guards. 1st Batt. R. Highlanders. 1st Batt. Scots Guards. 2nd Batt. R. Munster Fusiliers.
_Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL E. S. BULFIN. 2nd Batt. R. Sussex Regt. 1st Batt. Northampton Regt. 1st Batt. N. Lancs. Regt. 2nd Batt. K. R. Rifle Corps
_Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL H. J. S. LANDON. 1st Batt. R. W. Surrey Regt. 1st Batt. Gloucester Regt. 1st Batt. S. Wales Borderers. 2nd Batt. Welsh Regt.
CAVALRY (attached) C Squadron 15th Hussars.
ROYAL ENGINEERS 23rd and 26th Field Companies.
ROYAL ARTILLERY R.F.A. Batteries--113, 114, 115, 116, 117, 118, 46, 51, 54; (Howitzer) 30, 40, 57. _Heavy Battery R.G.A._--26. An Ammunition Column and an Ammunition Park.
_General Officer Commanding_--MAJOR-GENERAL C. C. MONRO.
_Brigade-Commander_--GENERAL R. SCOTT-KERR. 2nd Batt. Grenadier Guards 3rd Batt. Coldstream Guards 2nd Batt. Coldstream Guards lst Batt. Irish Guards.
_Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL R. C. B. HAKING.
2nd Batt. Worcester Regt. 2nd Batt. Highland L.I. 2nd Batt. Oxford and Bucks L.I. 2nd Batt. Connaught Rangers
_Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL R. H. DAVIES. 1st Batt. Liverpool Regt. 1st Batt. R. Berks Regt. 2nd Batt. S. Staffs. Regt. lst Batt. K. R. Rifle
CAVALRY (attached) B Squadron 15th Hussars.
ROYAL ENGINEERS 5th and 11th Field Companies.
_R.F.A. Batteries_--22, 50, 70, 15, 48, 71, 9, 16, 17; (Howitzer) 47, 56, 60. _Heavy Battery R.G.A._--35. An Ammunition Column and an Ammunition Park.
_A Division_ (_Four Brigades_)
General Officer Commanding--MAJOR-GENERAL E. H. H. ALLENBY.
_Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL C. J. BRIGGS.
2nd Dragoon Guards. 5th Dragoon Guards. 11th Hussars.
_Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL H. DE B. DE LISLE.
4th Dragoon Guards. 9th Lancers. 18th Hussars.
_Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL H. DE LA POER GOUGH.
4th Hussars. 5th Lancers. 16th Lancers.
_Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL HON. C. E. BINGHAM.
Household Cavalry (composite Regiment). 6th Dragoon Guards. 3rd Hussars.
_Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL SIR P. W. CHETWODE. 12th Lancers. 20th Hussars. 2nd Dragoons.
ROYAL HORSE ARTILLERY _Batteries_ "D," "E," "I," "J," "L."
_General Officer Commanding-in-Chief_-- GENERAL SIR H. L. SMITH-DORRIEN.
_General Officer Commanding_--MAJOR-GENERAL H. I. W. HAMILTON.
_Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL F. W. N. McCRACHEN.
3rd Batt. Worcester Regt. 1st Batt. Wilts Regt. 2nd Batt. S. Lancs. Regt. 2nd Batt. R. Irish Rifles.
_Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL B. J. C. DORAN.
2nd Batt. R. Scots. 4th Batt. Middlesex Regt. 2nd Batt. R. Irish Regt. 1st Batt. Gordon Highlanders.
_Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL F. C. SHAW. 1st Batt. Northumberland Fusiliers. 1st Batt. Lincolnshire Regt. 1st Batt. R. Scots Fusiliers. 4th Batt. R. Fusiliers.
CAVALRY (attached) A Squadron 15th Hussars.
ROYAL ENGINEERS 56th and 57th Field Companies.
_R.F.A. Batteries_--107, 108, 109, 6, 23, 49, 29, 41, 45; (Howitzer) 128, 129, 130. _Heavy Battery R. G. A._--48. An Ammunition Column and an Ammunition Park.
_General Officer Commanding_--MAJOR-GENERAL SIR C. FERGUSSON.
13th Infantry Brigade
_Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL G. J. CUTHBERT. 2nd Batt. K. O. Scottish Borderers. 1st Batt. R.W. Kent Regt. 2nd Batt. Yorks L.I. 2nd Batt. W. Riding Regt.
14th Infantry Brigade
_Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL S. P. ROLT. 2nd Batt. Suffolk Regt. 1st Batt. Duke of Cornwall's L.I. 1st Batt. East Surrey Regt. 2nd Batt. Manchester Regt.
15th Infantry Brigade
_Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL COUNT A. E. W. GLEICHEN.
1st Batt. Norfolk Regt. 1st Batt. Cheshire Regt. 1st Batt. Bedford Regt. 1st Batt. Dorset Regt.
CAVALRY (attached) A Squadron 19th Hussars.
ROYAL ENGINEERS 17th and 59th Field Companies.
ROYAL ARTILLERY _R.F.A. Batteries_--11, 52, 80, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124; (Howitzer) 37, 61, 65. _Heavy Battery R.G.A._--108. An Ammunition Column and an Ammunition Park.
19th Infantry Brigade
_Brigade Commander_--MAJOR-GENERAL L. G. DRUMMOND. 2nd Batt. R. Welsh Fusiliers. 1st Batt. Middlesex Regt. 1st Batt. Scottish Rifles. 2nd Batt. Argyll and Sutherland Highlanders.
Aeroplane Squadrons Nos. 2, 3, 4 and 5.
Horsed and Mechanical Transport.
ROYAL ARMY MEDICAL CORPS
There came into line at Le Cateau on August 25th the--
_General Officer Commanding_--MAJOR-GENERAL T. D. O. SNOW.
10th Infantry Brigade
Brigade Commander--BRIGADIER-GENERAL J. A. L. HALDANE. 1st Batt. R. Warwickshire Regt. 1st Batt. R. Irish Fusiliers. 2nd Batt. Seaforth Highlanders. 2nd Batt. R. Dublin Fusiliers.
11th Infantry Brigade
_Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL A. G. HUNTER-WESTON. 1st Batt. Somersetshire L.I. 1st Batt. Hampshire Regt. 1st Batt. E. Lancs. Regt. 1st Batt. Rifle Brigade.
12th Infantry Brigade
_Brigade Commander_--BRIGADIER-GENERAL H. F. M. WILSON. 1st Batt. R. Lancs. Regt. 2nd Batt. R. Inniskilling Fusiliers. 2nd Batt. Lancashire Fusiliers. 2nd Batt. Essex Regt.
CAVALRY (attached) B Squadron 19th Hussars.
ROYAL ENGINEERS 7th and 9th Field Companies.
_R.F.A. Batteries_--39, 68, 88 (xiv. Brigade); 125, 126, 127 (xxix Brigade); 27, 134, 135 (xxxii. Brigade); 31, 35, 55 (xxxvii. Brigade).
_Heavy Battery R.G.A._--31.
LINES OF COMMUNICATION AND ARMY TROOPS
1st Batt. Devonshire Regt. 1st Batt. Cameron Highlanders
The Retreat from Mons
_Now all the youth of England are on fire, And silken dalliance in the wardrobe lies; Now thrive the armourers, and honour's thought Reigns solely in the breast of every man._
August 5th, 1914! "Who would have dreamed of such a thing!" exclaimed the big majority. "So it has come at last," said the small minority.
Broadly speaking, there you have the country's opinion during those now dimly remembered days which followed immediately upon Germany's throwing down of the gauntlet.
Officers and men of our once-upon-a-time professional Army did not bother very much about it either way. War was their job. Active service was to be welcomed as a picnic change from the monotony of soldiering in England. Also, to the man keen on his profession (and since the Boer War such men have been steadily increasing in numbers) it meant the chance of promotion and of showing what he was made of.
A war, even long foreseen, must inevitably come as a surprise when it does actually break out, and this one was no exception. During the last week of that July there were very, very few in Aldershot who felt certain that the hour was at last striking.
But Aldershot was ready for it. For many a long year past Aldershot had existed for the Army. Latterly it had been the forge where Britain's little striking force, the spear-head of her armies, had been welded, sharpened and tested, made ready for instant launching. So, with the Fleet, were we prepared to fulfil our pact with France; or, if the summons came, to stand by Belgium.
Aldershot existed for war, and the comings and goings of troops passed almost unnoticed. True, it now became increasingly difficult to find rooms in the town, and the local outfitters promptly set to work to reap a golden harvest from the fantastic prices which they put upon war gear of all kinds, but that was all--at least to the eye of a casual observer.
There was Fritz, the doyen of Aldershot hairdressers. I wonder how much he learned in those days of the movements of units. Fritz had been an institution in the camps when present-day G.O.C.'s, grizzled and weather-beaten, had, as junior subalterns, sought his advice upon the training of incipient moustaches. Fritz remembered them all, could instantly reel off details of their careers, their regiments or stations, from the time they had left Aldershot until they had returned in senior commands. All duly pigeonholed in Berlin together with seemingly trivial incidents in their private lives.
Later on, sometime at the Aisne, rumour came round that Herr Fritz had been up to mischief of a more serious nature and that he had been duly lodged in prison, or shot, or something equally suitable.
Those were happy if very strenuous days at Aldershot that week or so before the embarkation. Men talked very little about the future, everyone was really too busy. Thoughts naturally flew back to the South African War when they did talk.
"Nobody was particularly keen on that," was the generally expressed opinion; "nobody wanted to kill the Boers; too one-sided. This--oh! this is the real thing. We've got our work cut out."
The very day after the mobilisation the Officers' Mess showed signs of packing up. It reminded one so much of the third act in _The Second in Command_. Two notices in the hall brought things home:--
"Officers may wear Service dress or blue undress jackets in Mess."
"Officers are particularly requested to pay their mess bills before leaving."
Packing-cases and parcels began to drift in and lie about: dozens of telegrams passed in and out: a smaller variety of dishes appeared at luncheon and dinner: the regimental band came and played to us every night (the cheerier spirits all took a hand at conducting, especially rag-time).
Everybody had his job, and nobody knew what anyone else was doing. Right at the beginning we experienced a curious feeling of secrecy. You would see an officer at lunch and miss him at dinner.
"Oh yes! I believe he has gone this afternoon," someone remarks.
"When are you off?" Colonel X. would say to an officer in a moment of forgetfulness, hastily adding, "No, I don't want to know--but, mind you pay your mess bill before you go."
This secrecy of movement was certainly the most striking feature of those early days: that, and the splendid organisation. We have got accustomed to it since, but at the time, and to men used to the happy-go-lucky methods of this dear, lovable, muddle-headed old country of ours, that organisation struck one as amazing.
On August 5th every C.O. was handed a file of documents. In these were given the most precise directions as to times, places and dates when his unit was to leave Aldershot. For instance:
"Train No. 463Y will arrive at siding B at 12.35 A.M., August 10th.
"You will complete loading by 3.40 A.M.
"This train will leave siding C at 9.45 A.M., August 10th.
"You will march on to the platform at 9.30 A.M. and complete your entraining by 9.40."
And I believe it is a fact that every train left five minutes ahead of its scheduled time. The London and South Western Railway was given sixty hours in which to send to Southampton 350 troop-trains. They did it in forty-five hours. "Some" hustle! The astonishing efficiency of it all, and the admirable co-operation between military and civil authorities. I very much doubt if there were more than two officers of the Staff at Aldershot H.Q. who knew details of the intended movements. Fritz must have been annoyed. C.O.'s, and other individual officers, who knew when their own unit was timed for departure, entered splendidly into the spirit of the game and loyally kept the information to themselves; would not even tell their people, nor their best girls.
One day the King came down. The visit was as secret as everything else. Each unit received about a quarter of an hour's warning of His Majesty's approach, and the men turned out of their tents or broke off their work to line up by the road. A few words of "good-bye, and good luck" to the men, a warm hand-clasp to the officers, three cheers, and the Royal car slipped forward to the next unit. One could hear the ripple of cheering flow round the camps as His Majesty passed.
By the way, it is a little curious how, from the very beginning, there have been just three words used by everyone in bidding "good-bye." "Good-bye, and good luck." A kind of spontaneous, universal formula. Officers used it, the men, mothers, wives and sweethearts.
"Good-bye, and good luck" to our sailors (It's a big debt we owe you to-day), "Good-bye, and good luck" to our soldiers (Some day we shall hope to repay). Though anxious the hearts left behind you, And a tear from the eye seems to fall, Yet--"good-bye"--God be with you, "good luck attend you, "Good-bye, and good luck to you all"--
as the refrain of a popular song had it later.
Impressions of those few hurried days are blurred. In a sense one had been through it all many times before. It differed but little from moving station or preparing for manoeuvres. And yet there was something of the glamour of an unknown future before one: an instinctive feeling that this was the end of soldiering as we had known it. Not that anyone dreamed of the war lasting beyond Christmas; there are no pessimists in the Army. We were all at school breaking up for the holidays, and I think that just about sums up the situation as we saw it at Aldershot. The unknown future was more on the lines of "Shall we get any skating?" "Will there be some good shows at the theatres?" "What sort of fun will the Pytchley give us?" "Shall I be able to get in the Hunt Ball?"
And so one has little enough to say about the days of mobilisation and packing up. Besides, quite enough has already been written to satisfy an interested public. One little adventure, however, seems worth recording. It befell a certain Gunner captain who was detailed to conduct a draft of men from one unit to another. The yarn has the merit of being true in every particular. It may form a small chapter to itself.
"Putting two and two together," said the A.S.C. major, "I imagine that you're to take this draft on to Portsmouth and hand over to the O.C. of the company down there."
Why a Gunner captain should have to conduct a draft of Field Gunners to a place like Portsmouth and hand them over to the tender mercies of an A.S.C. Company Commander, I couldn't imagine. Nor indeed why a Gunner should take his instructions from an A.S.C. major at all. But the Divisional C.R.A. had sent me up to him with the remark, "It looks as though you ought to report there," and that was all about it.
Mobilisation is responsible for a good many queer happenings, and here at Aldershot on the third day of it most men were rather at sea.
Even in those few hours one had learned not to ask questions. There was no objection to the asking, but the answer was usually a vacant, far-away look over the shoulder and "Eenteenth Brigade Office? Oh, it's over there"; and a wave of the arm would comprehensively include Farnborough, Deepcut and the Town Station.
And that was how the trouble began. If only the A.S.C. major had exercised a little imagination and made five out of his addition sum: if only he had read his own instructions a little more carefully (although we didn't know that till afterwards), a draft of tired Gunners would not have spent the next week trailing about the South of England looking for an A.S.C. company which didn't want them, and their officer would not have received a black mark which nearly damned his future chances at the very outset. But that by the way.
"The men had their breakfast at three this morning," and the cheery little subaltern, who had brought the draft down from Newcastle, saluted and discreetly made himself still smaller by vanishing hastily round the nearest corner.
I took my railway warrant and went out to have a look at the draft.
A fresh-looking lot they were; young, most of them, averaging about twenty-three years old; special reservists the senior sergeant told me. The few old hands, who sadly needed a shave and a wash, showed how young the rest of them were. I didn't take much stock of them, then. One doesn't when it's just a conducting job of a few hours, handing over, and back to Headquarters right away.
The men stood to attention, picked up their kits, and, with a "Fours left," we were off to the station down the shimmering, dancing, sandy roads of the Aldershot camps. The A.S.C. major returned to his ledgers and more arithmetic, and the cheery subaltern reclined at lordly ease in a Gunner Mess arm-chair, with a tinkling glass of gin and ginger beer at his elbow, and discussed the striking results of the previous day's battle in the North Sea--which had not taken place.
The station-master, who didn't look as worried as he felt, touched his cap.
"A local to ----, then change and go on to Reigate" (was it Reigate? I forget now, one visited so many out-of-the-way places), "and from there you'll probably get a through train to Portsmouth. If there isn't room in the train you can always turn people out."
Visions of burly, homespun-clad farmers and comfortable market-women being turned out, protesting, by a mere Gunner captain danced through my brain. Actions for assault and battery, damages, bail, prison.
"How an if they will not turn out?" said I.
And then I realised. This was War, red War; and Great Britain was mobilising. The needs of the State were paramount.
"You shall bid them turn out in the Prince's name," and, unlike Dogberry, shall see that you are obeyed.
And I made myself two inches taller because after all a Gunner captain was somebody in the world now. And people looked with a new interest at the lads in khaki and began to realise, perhaps for the first time, that they would have to count on the British Army even though it were "such a little one."
To do the good folk justice there was never a word of protest at the idea of having to turn out. And we had to invite them to do so a good many times before the company finished its tour of the Southern ports. Really it might have been a railway in Germany from the way the civilians gave road to the uniform. This change of attitude was certainly a vivid contrast to the days--last week was it?--when a man in His Majesty's uniform was looked at askance in crowded street and bar.
At Reigate, where we had to wait an hour, a bombardier, one of the old hands, begged leave to visit a certain hotel outside the station to buy some bread and cheese.
He was a man who hardly gave the appearance of being bread-and-cheese hungry, if you quite take my meaning, and the glassy stare with which this ancient tried to fix me augured ill for discipline if there were many others in the draft like him. Permission was refused. It was a trivial point gained but it had its consequences.
Portsmouth was reached in some five hours; and twenty minutes' march brought us to the A.S.C. barracks where a hot dinner would cheer us all; for I had remembered to send a telegram _en route_ to tell them to expect us.
We were received with cordiality by a decrepit old store-keeper, and the stables' cat. Otherwise the barracks looked as though an army had lately sacked the place from floor to basement.
The men looked glum, and there was more than a hint of a move to a near-by hotel for "bread and cheese." Well, they were only young reservists and discipline was an almost unknown quantity.
But dinner had to materialise somehow. So, demanding the keys of the castle from the unwilling seneschal, the senior sergeant, the bombardier, the stables' cat and myself started on a tour of inspection.
Good! The kitchen contained a sack of flour and most of a sheep. Apparently the sheep was intended to last the decrepit servitor and his struggling family for the rest of the week. But we paid no heed to tearful entreaties and ruthlessly tore the meat away from their very mouths.
"This is War," said I.
Soon dinner was well on the way, blankets were found for the men, and off I went to report to Headquarters.
H.Q. "received me most politely," as Harry Fragson used to sing, and didn't think they wanted me nor my company for any performance in Portsmouth.
"Come back to-morrow morning," said H.Q., "and we'll tell you."
The next day. "Oh, yes!" said H.Q., "you're Field Gunners, you're evidently sent here for Hilsea (two miles out): you'd better move on at once."
"Parade with kits in half an hour," I ordered.
Merrily we marched forth from the castle gates. Were we not wanted at Hilsea?
A cyclist orderly threw himself, panting, from his machine.
"H.Q.'s compliments and will you please report there at once."
"Halt! Fours about! Quick march!"
The author, a major in the Royal Field Artillery who shared in the retreat, dedicates this work to General Sir H. L. Smith-Dorrien, acknowledging the public's fascination with the retreat from Mons. Corbett-Smith admits the story can never be fully told by those who endured it, as the nightmare blurs facts, yet he attempts to capture the big, human side through trivial, homely incidents and stories of noble devotion. The narrative includes a dramatic account of a night attack at Landrecies, where a Coldstream Guards colonel shoots a spy using an electric torch, triggering a German assault. The fighting is described as a series of desperate, scattered engagements by exhausted men, culminating in a successful counterattack that drives the Germans out, leaving nearly 1,000 dead.
The Dedication and the Author's Intent
The book opens with a dedication letter to General Smith-Dorrien, revealing Corbett-Smith's original plan to cover the war from Mons to Ypres. He narrows the focus to the retreat, noting how little the public knows of it and how strongly they respond to the story. The author emphasizes the difficulty of telling the tale accurately, as survivors' memories are distorted by the nightmare. He aims to write of the big, human side, highlighting trivial, homely incidents and acts of chivalry by men like Francis Grenfell and Bradbury. This framing sets the tone for a personal, anecdotal account rather than a strategic analysis.
The Night Battle at Landrecies
The excerpt describes a German night attack on Landrecies, triggered when a Coldstream Guards colonel shoots a spy flashing an electric torch. The attack is likened to a smith's hammer on an anvil, with massed columns pouring into the town. British troops, exhausted and scattered, fight in small groups—three privates and a corporal here, a dozen men and a sergeant there—using only rifle flashes for light. The Guards rally for a supreme effort, breaking the German line and driving them out, leaving close upon 1,000 dead. The author notes that von Kluck staked heavily on this throw, pushing guns to point-blank range, but the British held.
The Human Scale of Combat
Corbett-Smith repeatedly emphasizes the fragmented, desperate nature of the fighting. Men tumbled out of houses in small groups, with no idea of forming ranks. The only light came from rifle flashes. The author uses vivid metaphors: the German column as a great mammoth, the Guards as tigers springing at head and flanks. The narrative stresses the bravery of both sides, but the British are portrayed as fighting for their lives against overwhelming numbers. The account of the night battle at Landrecies illustrates the chaos and heroism of the retreat, with the author's personal perspective as a participant lending authenticity to the description of exhaustion and improvisation.
Readers should approach this account as a participant's attempt to convey the human experience of a harrowing campaign, rather than a comprehensive military history. Corbett-Smith's focus on small incidents and individual acts of courage offers a ground-level view of the retreat, but his acknowledgment of blurred memories invites caution. The dedication and author's note provide context for his perspective, making this a valuable primary source for understanding how soldiers processed and narrated their experiences.
Reading about the quiet acts of devotion during that long retreat, I remembered my grandfather’s map case, worn smooth at the edges. He never spoke of Mons, only of the men who carried each other’s packs. That same weight of shared burden surfaced in The Story of Our Submarines — Background and Themes, where the dark water felt less like an enemy than a held breath between comrades.
Wyatt Baker
2 weeks agoWyatt Torres
3 weeks agoHarper Rivera
2 weeks agoMila Walker
1 month ago-
Jorge Taylor - 1 month ago
{'rating': 2, 'text': "While the author's experiences are undeniably significant, the book feels disjointed and lacks a clear overarching narrative. The constant focus on personal discomfort and minor skirmishes becomes tedious, and the broader strategic context is barely addressed. A more edited and contextualized version would have been far more valuable for readers."} -
Sean Smith - 2 weeks ago
{'rating': 5, 'text': "An indispensable firsthand account of the British Expeditionary Force's dramatic retreat from Mons in 1914. The author's vivid narrative puts you right in the mud and chaos of the march, capturing both the exhaustion and the unbroken spirit of the soldiers. For anyone seeking a gritty, human perspective on the opening days of World War I, this is essential reading."} -
Melody Turner - 1 week ago
{'rating': 3, 'text': "This is a valuable primary source for those interested in the Great War, offering a detailed soldier's-eye view of the retreat. The writing is engaging, though at times the narrative becomes a bit repetitive with the constant marching and fighting. It would benefit from a map to follow the movements, but overall it provides a solid, personal account."}
What did you think of this book?
Answer a few questions and save a private reflection on this device.
John Baker
3 weeks ago